A judge divides it. After approving the total settlement, or receiving a jury’s total verdict, the court apportions the money among the eligible relatives “in proportion to the losses suffered by each as determined by the court” (RSMo 537.095.3). Shares need not be equal, there is no minimum share, and a relative who proves no compensable loss can receive nothing.

A Missouri wrongful death recovery is not an inheritance. It is divided by loss, not by family tree, so being closest on paper does not decide who receives the most.

What Does RSMo 537.095 Actually Say?

Subsection 1 lets any one or more eligible relatives “compromise or settle the claim for damages with approval of any circuit court,” or sue “without joinder therein by any other person,” provided the claimant “shall satisfy the court that he has diligently attempted to notify all parties having a cause of action under section 537.080.” Any settlement or recovery is “for the use and benefit of those who sue or join, or who are entitled to sue or join, and of whom the court has actual written notice.” No wrongful death settlement is final until a circuit judge approves it.

Subsection 3 is the division rule. The jury “shall state the total damages found,” or on approving a settlement “the court shall state the total settlement approved.” Then “the court shall enter a judgment as to such damages, apportioning them among those persons entitled thereto in proportion to the losses suffered by each as determined by the court.”

Subsection 4 tells the court how the money moves. It orders the claimant to collect the judgment, “to deduct and pay the expenses of recovery and collection of the judgment and the attorneys’ fees as contracted,” to acknowledge satisfaction, “to distribute the net proceeds as ordered by the court,” and “to report and account therefor to the court.” The relative who signed holds the money for everyone the judgment names.

Who Decides the Shares, the Jury or the Judge?

The judge, in every case. Even after a trial, the jury’s job ends with the total. How the widow’s share compares to the mother’s comes back to the court under subsection 3.

Missouri’s intestacy rules do not decide the shares either, with one exception. When no spouse, child, grandchild, parent, sibling or sibling’s descendant can sue, the court appoints a plaintiff ad litem, and that recovery is distributed “according to the laws of descent unless special circumstances indicate that such a distribution would be inequitable” (RSMo 537.095.2). In the ordinary case brought by close family, loss controls, not the order of inheritance.

Only people the statute makes eligible can share. Our article at /blog/who-can-file-a-wrongful-death-lawsuit-in-missouri/ explains those classes. Banner ex rel. Bolduc v. Owsley noted that a stepson was not entitled to share (305 S.W.3d 498, Mo. App. S.D. 2010). In Parr v. Parr, the judgment as modified by the Missouri Supreme Court recited that the court had no authority to apportion any part of the settlement to the decedent’s grandchildren, whose parents were living (16 S.W.3d 332, Mo. banc 2000). Damages for what the person suffered before death are part of the same Missouri action (RSMo 537.090), and how that differs from a separate survival claim is covered at /blog/wrongful-death-vs-survival-action-in-missouri/.

What Does the Judge Weigh at the Apportionment Hearing?

The same factors a jury uses to set damages. RSMo 537.090 looks to “the pecuniary losses suffered by reason of the death, funeral expenses, and the reasonable value of the services, consortium, companionship, comfort, instruction, guidance, counsel, training, and support” of which each survivor has been deprived. The Missouri Supreme Court has said the judge apportioning a settlement is directed to consider exactly those things (Macke v. Patton, 591 S.W.3d 865, Mo. banc 2019).

The same statute says “damages for grief and bereavement by reason of the death shall not be recoverable.” In Parr, the trial court found that most of the parents’ damages were grief and bereavement, and the Supreme Court affirmed a judgment giving nearly all of the settlement to the widow of almost 34 years, who also offered evidence of the income her husband’s business would have produced.

The reported hearings show what courts receive:

  • Testimony about the relationship: how often the relative saw or spoke with the person who died and what the person did for them. In Macke the court heard from both parents, the father’s sister, the father’s wife and the mother’s husband.
  • Proof of money lost: tax returns, pay records and, in larger cases, an economist’s report on lost income and household services. The Parr court ordered the widow to produce three years of returns at the parents’ request.
  • Who paid the funeral and medical bills, because funeral expenses are a listed factor in RSMo 537.090.
  • Support the person was legally obligated to provide. Banner held that a child’s past-due and future court-ordered support are pecuniary losses the court must consider.
  • Money other relatives received because of the death. Banner held it was a misapplication of the law to give no weight to life insurance paid to the widow and daughter when measuring their pecuniary loss.

Illinois, for Metro East families, uses a different measure. The Illinois Wrongful Death Act has the court distribute the recovery to the surviving spouse and next of kin “in the proportion, as determined by the court, that the percentage of dependency of each such person upon the deceased person bears to the sum of the percentages of dependency of all such persons” (740 ILCS 180/2(b)). Illinois also allows damages “for grief, sorrow, and mental suffering” (740 ILCS 180/2(a)), which Missouri does not. An Illinois claim needs a lawyer licensed in Illinois.

The apportionment hearing measures what each person lost, not how much each person loved. Missouri law treats those as different questions, and the evidence has to be built around the first.

Can One Relative Receive Most of the Money, or Nothing at All?

Yes to both. “There is no minimum amount that must be awarded to any party,” and the court “is not bound by a set percentage or a minimum” (Parr, 16 S.W.3d 332). In Macke, the Supreme Court repeated that eligible relatives “are not guaranteed a certain amount by virtue of their statutory qualification.”

A share of zero is allowed. In Wright v. Cameron Mutual Insurance Co., the trial court gave the decedent’s father and mother nothing and divided the settlement between her husband and their young daughter. The Court of Appeals affirmed: “If one of the persons entitled to maintain suit suffered no damages, that person is not entitled to receive any part of the damages” (908 S.W.2d 867, Mo. App. S.D. 1995).

Equal shares are allowed too, even when relationships differ. In Keene v. Wilson Refuse, Inc., a ten-year-old son close to his father and a seventeen-year-old son from an earlier marriage who saw him less often received equal shares. The Court of Appeals affirmed, noting that a child’s loss is “not always susceptible of measurement simply by reference to the frequency of contact” (788 S.W.2d 324, Mo. App. E.D. 1990).

What Happens When an Estranged Parent, Child or Spouse Comes Forward?

They are entitled to notice and to be heard, and the judge decides what their loss is worth. Nothing in RSMo 537.080 or 537.095 disqualifies an absent parent. Missouri’s bar on a spouse who abandoned the other (RSMo 474.140) reaches “inheritance rights” and allowances “from the estate,” and wrongful death money goes to the relatives the court names, not to the estate. Absence is handled through the size of the share.

Macke came from the Circuit Court of the City of St. Louis. A 25-year-old man was killed in a crash. His father raised him; his mother, the Supreme Court said, “was absent from Nicklaus’ childhood,” and her claim rested mainly on being his birth mother and one chance meeting in 2016 and later social media contact. The circuit court gave 98 percent to the father and 2 percent to the mother, and the Supreme Court affirmed.

The rule protects absent children, too. In Banner, a 13-year-old whose father had not seen him since age four received 5 percent. The Court of Appeals reversed, holding the trial court had to count his child support losses and the others’ life insurance. The statute asks what the child “has been deprived of by reason of decedent’s death, not only what the decedent has failed to provide to date.”

A relative who never joined the lawsuit still shares. In Kavanaugh v. Mid-Century Insurance Co., a divorced father who dismissed himself from the case was still entitled to a share of the settlement, because the statute protects everyone “entitled to sue or join” (937 S.W.2d 243, Mo. App. W.D. 1996). He received 35 percent.

What if Family Members Cannot Agree?

Then the hearing is contested, and each relative, often with a separate lawyer, presents evidence. Agreement helps, but it does not bind the judge. In Parr, the widow proposed amounts for the children and parents; the court set its own.

Prepare early. In Macke, the mother received one continuance, hired a lawyer the morning of the reset hearing and was refused a second; the Supreme Court held that was not an abuse of discretion.

An appeal is not a second hearing. Macke held that an apportionment is reviewed like any other judge-tried case: whether it is supported by substantial evidence, is against the weight of the evidence, or erroneously declares or applies the law. The Court said earlier opinions using a “grossly excessive or inadequate” or abuse-of-discretion test, including Parr, Kavanaugh and Keene on that point, should no longer be followed, and that reversal on the weight of the evidence comes only “in rare cases.” The record made at the hearing usually decides the case.

How Are Attorney Fees Paid When Relatives Hire Different Lawyers?

Each relative pays his or her own lawyer, under his or her own contract, from his or her own share. RSMo 537.095.4(2) directs payment of “the attorneys’ fees as contracted.” Only “if there is no contract, or if the party sharing in the proceeds has no attorney representing him” may the court award the original plaintiff’s lawyer a fee from that person’s share “as the court deems fair and equitable.”

Keene applied the words strictly. The trial court ordered a son who had hired his own lawyer to pay one-third of his share to the lawyer who had filed the case and done the liability work. The Court of Appeals reversed. Where a valid fee contract is in evidence, the statute “simply does not permit” the court to substitute its own view of fairness, and the original lawyer’s “common fund” argument failed. The same court affirmed an order that each relative pay a proportionate share of the litigation expenses.

In Parr, expenses of recovery came off the total, then each person’s lawyer was paid from that person’s share. In Kavanaugh, no fee contract was in evidence, and the court refused to pay the father’s lawyer from the settlement because doing so would effectively charge the mother. Bring the signed fee agreement to the hearing.

How Is a Child’s Share Protected?

A child acts through a next friend or guardian ad litem, and the court must approve the child’s settlement and may approve the fee contract made on the child’s behalf (RSMo 507.184). A court in Wright appointed a guardian ad litem for the young daughter for the apportionment hearing.

After fees and expenses, if a child’s money exceeds $10,000, “the court shall order the next friend or guardian ad litem to pay or transfer such money or property to a duly appointed and qualified conservator of the minor” (RSMo 507.188.2). If it is $10,000 or less, the court may instead authorize a deposit payable to the child at 18, delivery to a suitable person, or payment to a parent or custodian, held as the court directs (RSMo 475.330.1; 507.188.1).

Some settlements are structured, paid over time instead of in one lump sum, as Keene’s was.

Can Hospitals, Creditors or Medicaid Take Part of the Recovery?

A wrongful death claim belongs to the family, not to the person who died. The Missouri Supreme Court has described it as “a new and distinct cause of action” that accrues to the beneficiaries at the moment of death, and held that a hospital lien on the patient’s own injury claims does not attach to a wrongful death settlement (American Family Mutual Insurance Co. v. Ward, 774 S.W.2d 135, Mo. banc 1989). The decedent’s unpaid bills remain claims against the estate, a separate proceeding.

MO HealthNet, Missouri’s Medicaid program, is different. If it paid for the person’s care, RSMo 208.215 names “persons entitled under section 537.080 to bring an action for wrongful death” among those who must notify the MO HealthNet division of the claim and of any recovery and reimburse it from the proceeds (RSMo 208.215.3, .6).

On taxes, federal law excludes from gross income “the amount of any damages (other than punitive damages) received” on account of personal physical injuries or physical sickness (26 U.S.C. 104(a)(2)). Punitive damages fall outside that exclusion by its terms. A tax professional should review any particular recovery.

When to Call About Dividing a Recovery

Before anyone signs a settlement or files for approval, and as soon as you receive notice of a hearing. The underlying claim must be filed within three years (RSMo 537.100), and a claim against a government body can require earlier notice. Our wrongful death page at /wrongful-death/ covers the rest of the claim.

Call The Injury Counsel at (314) 727-7220 for a free, confidential consultation. We identify every relative who must be notified, gather the records the RSMo 537.090 factors call for, and prepare the testimony your share depends on.