When the injury caused the death, Missouri allows one claim: the family’s wrongful death action, which also recovers the pain, suffering and medical bills the person endured before dying (RSMo 537.090). A separate survival action exists only when the injured person died of something else. That claim belongs to the estate and is brought by its personal representative (RSMo 537.020).

In Missouri the family does not choose between the two claims. The medical cause of death chooses for them.

Why Is There Only One Claim When the Injury Caused the Death?

Because of how the statutes are written. The survival statute keeps alive “causes of action for personal injuries, other than those resulting in death” (RSMo 537.020.1). The wrongful death statute applies “whenever the death of a person results from” conduct that would have let the person sue had death not ensued (RSMo 537.080.1).

The Missouri Supreme Court calls the two statutes “mutually antagonistic” (Wollen v. DePaul Health Center, 828 S.W.2d 681, Mo. banc 1992) and “two sides of a single coin”: an action for personal injuries that result in death may only be brought under the wrongful death statute (Mickels v. Danrad, 486 S.W.3d 327, Mo. banc 2016).

The injured person’s own claim is folded into the family’s case. RSMo 537.090 provides: “In addition, the trier of the facts may award such damages as the deceased may have suffered between the time of injury and the time of death and for the recovery of which the deceased might have maintained an action had death not ensued.” The same section says “damages for grief and bereavement by reason of the death shall not be recoverable.”

Pre-death medical expenses and pain and suffering are recoverable in the wrongful death claim, but nothing is allowed for the shortened life itself (Powell v. American Motors Corp., 834 S.W.2d 184, Mo. banc 1992), and even the pre-death damages are paid to the wrongful death plaintiffs, not on the deceased person’s behalf (Lawrence v. Beverly Manor, 273 S.W.3d 525, Mo. banc 2009). Who may bring the action, and the rest of its damages, are covered in our article at /blog/who-can-file-a-wrongful-death-lawsuit-in-missouri/.

When Does a Separate Survival Claim Exist?

When the defendant hurt the person but something else killed them. Then the injury claim “shall not abate” at death. It survives to the personal representative of the injured person, “and the liability and the measure of damages shall be the same as if such death or deaths had not occurred” (RSMo 537.020.1). It is the claim the person could have filed while alive, for bills, lost wages and pain up to death.

Mickels shows the line. A doctor allegedly missed a brain tumor on an MRI. The tumor was incurable either way, and the evidence was that earlier diagnosis would have bought about six more months. Because the negligence did not cause the death, the family could not sue for wrongful death. But the negligence injured him, and the Court held that claim survives and can be brought by his personal representative under RSMo 537.020 (Mickels v. Danrad, 486 S.W.3d 327, Mo. banc 2016).

Ownership is strict. In a case from the Circuit Court of the City of St. Louis, a woman fell in a Schnucks parking lot and later died of what her children said were unrelated causes. The children sued in their own names. The Court of Appeals affirmed dismissal for lack of standing: her claim “survived only to a personal representative,” and a court determination that the children were her heirs did not change that (Sauter v. Schnuck Markets, Inc., 803 S.W.2d 54, Mo. App. E.D. 1990).

Can the Estate Sue for Pain and Suffering Before Death?

Only if the injury did not cause the death. In that case the personal representative sues for the person’s pain and suffering under RSMo 537.020, and the money comes into the estate.

If the injury did cause the death, the estate has no claim of its own. The pre-death pain and suffering is still recoverable, but by the wrongful death plaintiffs under RSMo 537.090. The rule holds even when no family exists. A woman struck by a car died seventeen days later, apparently with no living relatives and a will leaving her property to charities. Her estate sought her pre-death suffering, medical bills and funeral costs. The Missouri Supreme Court affirmed dismissal: the estate is not entitled to share in a wrongful death recovery, which passes to the statutory relatives or to those who take “according to the laws of descent” (Sullivan v. Carlisle, 851 S.W.2d 510, Mo. banc 1993).

How Do the Two Claims Compare?

  • Who brings it. Wrongful death: a family member in the classes listed in RSMo 537.080, or a plaintiff ad litem when no one in those classes exists. Survival: the personal representative of the estate appointed by the probate division (RSMo 537.020.2, 537.021.1), or, only in lost-chance cases, a plaintiff ad litem (RSMo 537.021.1(1)).
  • Who receives the money. Wrongful death: the relatives entitled to share, as the court apportions it among them in proportion to their losses (RSMo 537.095.3). Our article at /blog/how-is-a-wrongful-death-settlement-divided-in-missouri/ explains that division. Survival: the estate, then the heirs or the beneficiaries named in a will after probate.
  • Whose creditors can reach it. A wrongful death claim vests in the survivors at death, so a hospital lien on the patient’s own claims does not attach to its settlement (American Family Mutual Insurance Co. v. Ward, 774 S.W.2d 135, Mo. banc 1989). MO HealthNet is an exception, covered in the settlement article. A survival recovery is collected by the personal representative (RSMo 473.270) and is part of an estate that pays allowed claims, including funeral and last-illness expenses, before distribution (RSMo 473.397). Most creditor claims not filed within one year after death are barred (RSMo 473.444).
  • What it covers. Wrongful death: the family’s losses plus the deceased person’s pre-death damages (RSMo 537.090). Survival: only the injured person’s own damages, measured as if death had not occurred (RSMo 537.020.1).
  • Punitive damages. Wrongful death allows “aggravating circumstances attending the death” to be considered (RSMo 537.090), and a punitive award is defined to include “an award for aggravating circumstances,” so the clear and convincing standard applies (RSMo 510.261.1, .9). A survival claim carries the injured person’s own measure of damages, including the same punitive standard (RSMo 537.020.1).
  • Deadline. Wrongful death: three years after the cause of action accrues (RSMo 537.100), which is the death. Survival: the injured person’s own limitations period, explained below.

Does a Survival Claim Require Opening an Estate?

Almost always. A wrongful death claim needs no probate; a qualifying family member files it. A survival claim needs a personal representative, appointed on a beneficiary’s written application (RSMo 537.020.2), and timing matters: “no letters of administration shall be issued unless application is made to the court for such letters within one year from the date of death,” with an exception for cases under RSMo 537.021 (RSMo 473.050.6). That exception, and the plaintiff ad litem alternative, are written only for cases “involving loss chance of recovery or survival” (RSMo 537.021.1(1)).

The underlying claim keeps its own deadline. Most injury claims must be brought within five years (RSMo 516.120). Claims against physicians, hospitals and other health care providers must be brought within two years from the date of the act of neglect, with narrow exceptions (RSMo 516.105). Death does not restart either period. Missouri’s statute giving an executor one year after death applies to a person entitled to sue who was under a legal disability, such as a person under twenty-one or mentally incapacitated (RSMo 516.170, 516.180).

Filing in the wrong capacity can cost the claim. A daughter filed a lost-chance survival claim in her own name in time, but was appointed personal representative only after the two-year period ran. Her later suit was barred: as an individual and as personal representative she was two legally different plaintiffs, and relation back did not save it (Smith v. Tang, 926 S.W.2d 716, Mo. App. E.D. 1996).

A survival claim can be lost twice: once to the injured person’s own limitations period, and once to the one-year limit on opening an estate.

What Is a Lost Chance of Survival Claim?

It is a medical malpractice claim for the loss of a chance to recover. In Wollen, a man with gastric cancer allegedly would have had a 30 percent chance of survival and cure if properly diagnosed. Because a statistic cannot prove any one patient would have lived, his widow could not sue for wrongful death, but the Court recognized a lost chance claim under the survivorship statute, brought by the personal representative (Wollen v. DePaul Health Center, 828 S.W.2d 681, Mo. banc 1992).

Under RSMo 537.021.1(1), the court “shall appoint a plaintiff ad litem” at the request of the plaintiff or a person listed in RSMo 537.080, that person is “entitled to the proceeds,” and the plaintiff ad litem “may maintain the action as an alternative theory in any action under section 537.080.” The deadline is still the malpractice deadline: two years under RSMo 516.105, not the three-year wrongful death period (Markham v. Fajatin, 325 S.W.3d 455, Mo. App. E.D. 2010).

What if the Cause of Death Is Disputed?

Then both claims are usually pleaded, in the alternative. Missouri’s rules allow a party to “set forth two or more statements of a claim or defense alternately or hypothetically” and to “state as many separate claims or defenses as the party has regardless of consistency” (Rule 55.10). The wrongful death count is brought by the family member; the survival count is brought by the personal representative, who has to be appointed in time for the survival count to be valid.

Example: a resident of a nursing home in St. Louis County falls, breaks a hip and dies weeks later. If the fall and its complications caused the death, the family has a wrongful death claim that includes her pain from the fall. If she died of an unrelated heart condition, the fall claim survives to her estate. The answer also matters for an arbitration agreement signed at admission: one covering claims “derived through” the resident did not bind her family’s wrongful death claim, which is not derivative of hers (Lawrence v. Beverly Manor, 273 S.W.3d 525, Mo. banc 2009). A survival claim is her own.

Example: a driver is badly hurt in a crash on Interstate 64 and dies months later of a cancer the defense says had nothing to do with the crash. If so, the crash claim survives to the estate. If the medical evidence connects the death to the crash injuries, it is a wrongful death case.

The medical evidence decides which claim exists: the death certificate, any autopsy, the records between injury and death, and testimony from treating physicians or a forensic pathologist. Because the deadlines differ, the shorter clock has to be protected while that evidence is gathered.

What Happens if the Injured Person Dies While the Lawsuit Is Pending?

The case does not end, but it must be moved into the right hands. “If a party dies and the claim is not thereby extinguished, the court may, upon motion, order substitution of the proper parties.” Any party or person in interest may suggest the death, and “unless a motion for substitution is served within 90 days after a suggestion of death is filed, the action shall be dismissed as to the deceased party without prejudice” (Rule 52.13(a)(1)).

If the death came from something else, the personal representative is substituted and the case goes on as a survival claim (RSMo 537.020.1). If the injury caused the death, the case is amended to state wrongful death. In a benzene case, a man sued in the City of St. Louis over leukemia and then died, and an amended petition alleging wrongful death followed. The Missouri Supreme Court held the amendment was not a new cause of action for venue purposes and ordered the case sent back to the City (State ex rel. Burns v. Whittington, 219 S.W.3d 224, Mo. banc 2007). In Sanders v. Ahmed, 364 S.W.3d 195 (Mo. banc 2012), the estate was substituted after the patient died and a wrongful death claim was later added.

A lifetime loss does not necessarily end the family’s claim. Where a smoker lost part of her own federal suit on summary judgment and the rest was dismissed with prejudice after her death, the Court of Appeals held her survivors’ wrongful death action was not barred (Smith v. Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp., 275 S.W.3d 748, Mo. App. W.D. 2008).

What if the Injury Happened in Illinois?

Illinois keeps two separate statutes. Its Wrongful Death Act action is brought in the name of the personal representative for the exclusive benefit of the surviving spouse and next of kin, may include damages for “grief, sorrow, and mental suffering,” and must generally be commenced within two years after the death (740 ILCS 180/1, 180/2). Its Survival Act preserves actions “to recover damages, including punitive damages when applicable, for an injury to the person” (755 ILCS 5/27-6), with no exception for injuries that resulted in death, so the two claims can stand side by side. A claim under Illinois law needs a lawyer licensed in Illinois.

When to Call

Before deciding which claim you have. The answer depends on the medical cause of death, and the survival claim can depend on an estate being opened within a year. Our wrongful death page at /wrongful-death/ covers the rest of a Missouri death case.

Call The Injury Counsel at (314) 727-7220 for a free, confidential consultation. We will review the medical records on the cause of death, identify which claim or claims your family has, and tell you who needs to be appointed and by when.